More Good Reviews Review: A Cheap Lifetime Deal With Clear Caps

A customer is thrilled with the work you did on Tuesday. They tell their spouse and maybe a neighbour. They never write a Google review, because nobody asked and it’s one more task on a busy evening. Meanwhile a customer who had a bad week leaves two stars without any prompting. If that imbalance sounds familiar, More Good Reviews is aimed squarely at it.

What it does once a job is finished

This is a review request tool. According to the listing, it sends email and SMS requests as soon as a job is done, with reminders and follow-ups built in. A single dashboard tracks every request, every reminder and every response, so you can see who was asked, who ignored you and who answered.

That’s the core, and it’s a sensible core. Most small businesses don’t have a review problem so much as an asking problem. Automating the ask, and the polite second nudge, is where most of the value sits.

The listing names Birdeye and Podium as the products it stands in for. Treat that as positioning. It tells you which category the seller wants to be compared in, not how the features match up.

Star-first routing and the AI replies

The feature you’ll hear about most is star-first routing. Happy customers are sent straight to Google or Facebook. Unhappy ones land on a private feedback form first, so you hear the complaint before the internet does.

I like the idea of catching problems early. I’m more cautious about steering only the happy people to public sites, because review platforms have their own rules about filtering. The listing doesn’t discuss that, so read Google’s current policy before you build your whole process around it.

The AI side is broader. You get drafted or automatic replies to Google and Facebook reviews, summaries and trend highlights, and automatic tagging of customers and reviews. Replies can be sent, edited, or go out on their own.

My advice is to keep a human in the loop for anything below four stars. An automatic reply to an angry customer is a risk you don’t need. Drafts you approve are the safer setting, and the listing says that option exists.

There’s one catch to keep in mind. The listing says that if a new feature is resource-intensive, you may be asked to add your own API key or connect a third-party service under your own account. So the AI may not stay fully included as it grows.

The extras around the core

Beyond requests and replies, the plan table lists a few practical pieces:

• Review pages and a branded showcase page
• QR codes and an in-store kiosk mode
• Unlimited embeddable website widgets
• A custom domain for your emails and review pages
• Connections to other tools: Google My Business, SMS, Zapier and MCP

The QR code and kiosk mode matter if you serve people face to face, like a salon or a repair counter. The custom domain is a good touch, since requests that come from your own name tend to look less like spam. The listing also says API and MCP access come with every code, which is useful if you want to connect it to your own automations.

What the $79 actually buys

The deal is a stackable lifetime plan. Each code is $79 and, per the listing’s FAQ, carries just two limits: 5,000 monthly requests and 20 locations. Everything else is included with every code.

Stack up to five codes, and no more. The pricing works out like this:

• 1 code, $79: 20 locations, 5,000 requests a month
• 2 codes, $158: 40 locations, 10,000 requests
• 3 codes, $237: 60 locations, 15,000 requests
• 4 codes, $316: 80 locations, 20,000 requests
• 5 codes, $395: 100 locations, 25,000 requests

The per-code numbers come from the FAQ, and the location counts match the plan table. Ignore the crossed-out list prices of $1,428 to $7,140. They’re an anchor, not a price anyone pays.

For a single shop, one code is plenty. 5,000 requests a month is a lot of customers. For an agency, the five-code tier is the one to look at, since it’s described as room for 100 single-location clients.

If you outgrow the caps, the listing says you upgrade your subscription and keep the usage you already paid for. It doesn’t say what that subscription costs. That’s a gap, and it matters if you plan to grow into the ceiling.

You also get future updates to the plan, and if the plan is renamed your deal maps to the new name. Redeem within 60 days. The listing mentions a 60-day money-back guarantee, which makes the risk low.

Where the listing gets murky

The plan table is hard to read. It shows more values per row than there are lifetime tiers, and some rows look like they mix the lifetime tiers with regular subscription plans. A few columns show a customer cap of 3, and one column has email requests, review pages and comprehensive AI switched off. I can’t tell which of those apply to the deal.

White label is the clearest conflict. The FAQ says you need five codes. The table appears to show white label on the three-code tier as well. If branding matters to your agency, get that answer in writing before you pay.

SMS is the other open question. The listing says SMS requests are included and lists SMS as an integration, but it doesn’t say whether message costs are bundled or whether you connect your own provider. Texting usually has a cost somewhere, so ask.

Finally, this is a young product that has changed direction. AppSumo’s own summary says the tool has evolved to focus on review management, and that some buyers wanted more customization. With 81 reviews averaging 4.93, buyer sentiment looks strong. Still, that summary is marketing copy, and we haven’t used the tool ourselves.

Who should skip it

Skip it if your reviews live mostly somewhere other than Google and Facebook. Those are the only review sources the listing names, so Yelp-heavy or industry-directory businesses should check first.

Skip it if you want a full customer messaging suite. This is about review requests and replies, and the listing doesn’t claim more.

Skip it, or at least start with one code, if you aren’t sure you’ll send requests consistently. Software can’t fix a business that never asks or never finishes jobs on time.

The sensible way in is a single $79 code on one location. Set up your first request flow in the first week, and put your refund deadline in the calendar before you do anything else.